ESL Learning

Paper Summary:

This paper discusses the actual and perceived competence of the ESL individual while communicating in the English language. More specifically, the paper centers the discussion on the concept of heterogeneous (communication) competence. It draws from the theories and concepts of linguists such as N. Chomsky, M. Stubbs and M. Halliday and R. Hasan. The paper posits that heterogeneous communication competence is a pragmatic concept that is developed, ironically, from linguistic theories and concepts.

Table of Contents:
Introduction
The Case Under Study
Analysis
Noam Chomsky: "Competence" And "Performance" In The ESL Context
Michael Stubbs: Vocabulary Generation & Development And Communication Competence
M. Halliday & R. Hasan: Communication Competence And Social Relations

From the Paper:

"Looking into Marcella's narrative highlights this important insight by Halliday and Hasan. As previously mentioned in the preceding section, Marcella's use of the word "braves," rather than "waves," can create confusion to the other communicator when expressed. However, communication roles are assumed in the process of understanding her narrative: as the listener of the story, the other communicator seeks to understand the meaning of "braves" in the context of Marcella's story. Though this is the ideal situation--that is, the other communicator would seek understanding in making sense of Marcella's story--there will be cases in which she may not be understood by other listeners/communicators, and at the worst, being labeled as incompetent as a communicator because of her wrong word choice and usage. Power relations (conflict) emerges when this happens, wherein the other communicator, more knowledgeable of the English language, fails to understand the context in which Marcella's story is applied, thereby generating confusion and ineffective communication between Marcella and the communicator."

Sample of Sources Used:

• Chomsky, N. and M. Halle. (1991). The sound pattern of English. Cambridge: MIT Press.
• Smith, N. (1999). Chomsky: Ideas and Ideals. NY: Cambridge UP.
• Stubbs, M. (1986). "Language development, lexical competence, and nuclear vocabulary." In K. Durkin (ed.). Language development in the school years. (1986). Blackwell.
• Young, R. (1992). Critical theory and classroom talk. Clevedon.

More papers on ESL Learning:

• Term Paper # 121429 : "Technology in ESL Learning"
• Research Paper # 10769 : "Translation Use in ESL Learning"
• Essay # 69712 : "ESL Strategies"

APA Citation:

MLA Citation: