James Joyce's "A Painful Case"

Paper Summary:

This paper explains that, in James Joyce's "A Painful Case", the reason why the protagonist Mr. Duffy breaks off his relationship with Mrs. Sinico is that his greatest problem is not an absence of emotions but rather an isolation from society and from his own self. The author points out that Mr. Duffy is a very confused man due to his lack of experience with emotions, especially with love; therefore, he imposes emotional isolation on himself in order to protect himself from his own confusions, especially the ones concerning his sexual identity. The paper stresses that Mr. Duffy definitely does not face his own difficulties and crucial decisions; his only attempt to open up has made him crawl back and shut himself in; thereby, the life he chooses is a life of emotional isolation.

From the Paper:

"James Joyce's "A Painful Case" is a story about the life of Mr. Duffy, an isolated person, who has no friends or family and lives his life in a constant routine. One night at a concert, he meets another member of the audience, Mrs. Sinico. A relationship is developed between the two characters. Mr. Duffy seems to be interested in this relationship and in Mrs. Sinico, after all "This union [between them] exalted him, wore away the rough edges of his character, emotionalized his mental life." (122). However, at some point in the story he decides to break it off. The reader feels that this relationship with Mrs. Sinico is Mr. Duffy's only chance of experiencing genuine emotions of love and happiness and his only opportunity of a close relationship with another person, other than himself. Thus, his decision to break off this relationship frustrates the reader's expectations and provokes puzzlement."

More papers on James Joyce's "A Painful Case":

• Analytical Essay # 37211 : "A Painful Case"
• Analytical Essay # 27202 : "Love in James Joyce's "Dubliners"
• Analytical Essay # 59908 : "Notion of the Outsider in Dubliners?"

APA Citation:

MLA Citation: