A discussion of the "Frye", "Daubert" and "Carmichael" Supreme Court decisions and their criteria for expert scientific witness qualifications.
Written in 2009; 798 words; 4 sources; APA; $ 28.95
Paper Summary:
The paper discusses the 1923 U.S. Supreme Court's "Frye" decision that generated the limited criteria used by courts to determine the qualification of proffered scientific expert witnesses in federal cases. The paper then discusses the "Daubert" case that expanded the criteria for expert scientific witness qualifications and highlights the inappropriateness of "Frye" as well as "Daubert" to fire investigation.
The paper then looks at the 1999 "Carmichael" case that finally resolved the conflicting standards articulated under Frye and Daubert, by including non-scientific evidence as well as scientific evidence, offering a tremendous improvement for fire investigators.
Outline:
Introduction - The Frye Decision and the Evolution of Modern Evidence Standards
The Expansion of Criteria for Expert Scientific Witness Qualification
The Inappropriateness of Frye to Fire Investigation
Conclusion - Carmichael, Federal Rule 702, and Implications for Fire Investigation
From the Paper:
"The 1923 U.S. Supreme Court's Frye decision generated the criteria used by courts to determine the foundational qualification of proffered scientific expert witnesses in federal cases. Specifically, Frye introduced the general acceptance standard necessary to qualify the particular field of science supporting the intended testimony of expert witnesses (Cleary 2007). According to the Frye criterion, in order for expert witness testimony to be admissible, the underlying field of science corresponding to the intended testimony, must be "generally accepted" within the scientific community."
We have thousands of high-quality term papers, research papers, essays, book reports and dissertations on every topic. At AcaDemon, you can download those term papers to help you write yours! You can be sure that the term paper, essay, book report or research paper you download are top-quality, competitively priced and high-level work.
This Free Term Paper Abstract is a part of our Term Paper Library.Here you can purchase research papers, examples of essays, academic dissertations, articles, notes, analytical papers, book reports, stories and poems. We have thousands of persuasive, point-of-view, narrative, critical, compare and contrast and other types of essays in our Library. You can also find here Term papers on "Expert Scientific Witness Testimony", Essays on "Expert Scientific Witness Testimony", Research papers on "Expert Scientific Witness Testimony", Student papers on "Expert Scientific Witness Testimony", Book reports on "Expert Scientific Witness Testimony", Dissertation on "Expert Scientific Witness Testimony", Thesis on "Expert Scientific Witness Testimony", Summary of paper on "Expert Scientific Witness Testimony", Articles written on "Expert Scientific Witness Testimony".
Look for more research papers, essays and book reports on